The controversy went on for at least three more years p. Some even in the mainstream did not think the issues were very serious. Some of those who were excommunicated started their own churches. Some of those opposed to free grace theology began to emphasize even more strongly the necessity of good works for salvation and assurance. Winship strongly believes that the problem came to the forefront because political people like Vane and a popular preacher like Cotton became involved.
Cotton was popular in both the colonies and England as a speaker. After the controversy, he once again enjoyed that status. The book is informative because it shows that a theological debate can have others factors driving the controversy.
- Log in to Wiley Online Library?
- DNA Methods in Clinical Microbiology.
- Find a copy in the library;
For instance, Vane was involved politically both in the colony and in England. It may be that his support of Hutchinson was based partially on political considerations. Winship believes that Puritanism was flexible enough to allow theological differences and that these other factors dictated what happened. For the readers of the JOTGES , this book shows that the issues of assurance and the essence of saving faith are not things that only recently appeared on the theological scene.
It is safe to say that people in Christendom have wondered about these things from the very beginning.
Winship reminds us that even in theological controversies it is possible that people have various motives. The book is very well annotated. It is not an easy read because it deals with many different people and different intrigues.
Making Heretics - Michael P Winship - Bok () | Bokus
It also uses many quotes using seventeenth century English. Since Winship deals with motives, not all historical scholars agree with his findings. However, the book is extremely interesting and deals with issues near and dear to those who are involved in the Free Grace movement. I highly recommend the book. Journal Articles. Book Reviews.
Posted in Book Reviews. Jonathan Tomes marked it as to-read Apr 25, RevolutionaryPA added it Jun 09, Ashley added it Jul 09, Joshua marked it as to-read Feb 24, Alyssa marked it as to-read Mar 02, A added it May 24, Charlie marked it as to-read Oct 22, Apexx marked it as to-read Oct 23, BookDB marked it as to-read Nov 19, Jack marked it as to-read May 26, Paige Collins marked it as to-read Oct 25, Erin added it Dec 17, Katy marked it as to-read Sep 15, Violaly added it Nov 09, Ted Morgan marked it as to-read Feb 07, Sean marked it as to-read Aug 07, Erin Lyons is currently reading it Oct 25, Gregory Johannes is currently reading it Feb 17, There are no discussion topics on this book yet.
North American Hi About Michael P. Michael P.
You are here:
A specialist in the history of religion in colonial America, Michael Winship is professor of history at the University of Georgia, where he holds the E. Merton Coulter Chair.
A chapter on New England religion from the ss, "Congregationalist Hegemony in New England, from the s to the s," is in the Cambridge History of Religions in America, vol I New York, , and a chapter on the various early forms of English church establishments in the Americas, '' British America to I Oxford, Books by Michael P. Trivia About Making Heretics No trivia or quizzes yet. Welcome back. Shepard's increasingly venomous conservatism drove Hutchinson further toward radicalism, and her growing radicalism, in turn, pulled the relatively moderate Winthrop into the fray as her chief legal opponent.
Winthrop's lead role in Hutchinson's banishment generated widespread resentment in Boston, which led to his unseating as Governor of the Massachusetts Bay Colony, and to the election of the religious radical, Henry Vane.
Although short-lived, Vane's governorship had the further unsettling effect of calling unfavorable attention in England, where Vane was prominent and well regarded, to intolerance and confusion in Boston. In the most skillful way, Winship shows that advocates of free grace and proponents of religious intolerance were not simply adversaries, but also creatures of each other's imaginations.
- The Scar of Race;
- Studies in Atatürks Turkey: The American Dimension (Ottoman Empire and Its Heritage).
- Redressing the Emperor: Improving Our Childrens Public Mental Health System (Contemporary Psychology).
- Article excerpt.
- Account Options!
- Making heretics : militant protestantism and Free Grace in Massachusetts, 1636-1641.
The implications of this conclusion are far-reaching. One need only think about the antagonism today between seekers and fundamentalists to appreciate the ongoing relevance of Winship's discoveries about the ways in which a tiny Puritan community in seventeenth-century New England established patterns of religious and cultural interaction that still persist in the United States today. Project MUSE promotes the creation and dissemination of essential humanities and social science resources through collaboration with libraries, publishers, and scholars worldwide. Forged from a partnership between a university press and a library, Project MUSE is a trusted part of the academic and scholarly community it serves.
Built on the Johns Hopkins University Campus.